0 of 823 items. 135 missables still open. 2 endings. About 250h to go.
Saved on this device only.Save to cloud
This guide finishes everything in one playthrough. It follows the story chapter by chapter with Arthur on the high-honor path, and each mission says which choice keeps his honor up. Every chapter closes some content behind it, so read each warning before the mission it sits above. Most map collectibles wait for the region sweeps after the story, when the whole map is open and nothing can be lost. Gold medals can be replayed after the credits, but the first run is easier.
The blizzard keeps Arthur in Colter between missions; riding off alone gets him killed, so there is no free roam until the chapter ends. Nothing here counts toward a missable trophy. The only things to watch are the unique horse and two letters on the train.
Once "Who the Hell is Leviticus Cornwall?" ends, the private car is gone. Before you start the engine, take the Oil Company Letter to Cornwall and the Mining Company Letter to Cornwall from its desk (both optional).
From here to the end of Chapter 4 the camp has three systems that close for good with "Banking, The Old American Art". Tithing box beside Dutch's tent: your own cash or valuables count toward Give to the Poor ($250 in all); $20 or more at once also raises honor. Item requests: gang members stop you in camp (mostly 8:00 to 20:00) and ask for an item; talk to them again with it. More open once you have done a mission with someone. Five delivered gives Errand Boy, and some givers ask only in Chapter 2. Companion activities: a member invites you out (a hunt, a robbery); one in each of the three camps gives Friends With Benefits. They are random, so if none shows, sleep or move the story on. Each request and activity is listed where it is easiest.
Two Chapter 6 honor missions need honor level 4 of 8, and the ending this route takes is the high-honor one. Greet people, help strangers, do camp chores, release fish and give $20 or more to the box; each mission below names its honorable choice.
Before "Polite Society, Valentine Style" ends, pull Jimmy Brooks up from the cliff edge. It locks: Pen (Jimmy Brooks) (optional).
You meet Thomas Downes at his table by the Valentine stable only once, before or after "Americans at Rest". Before you leave it, take the Charity Handbill (optional).
Máximo's map near Flatneck Station leads to Caliban's Seat, then Cotorra Springs, then two gold bars on O'Creagh's Run, which you reach in "Exit Pursued by a Bruised Ego". This chain is the one treasure hunt 100% needs and covers Explorer 1 to 4. The bars can go straight into the tithing box: valuables count toward Give to the Poor.
Before you ride away from Granger's Hoggery, take the revolver from Granger's body. It locks: Granger's Revolver (optional).
Before you leave Cairn Lodge, take the revolver from Flaco's body. It locks: Flaco's Revolver (optional).
Putting a Money Lending debt into the tithing box opens the ledger. Its upgrades are optional: none counts for 100% or a trophy. Dutch's tent ($220) and then Arthur's lodging ($325) add a fast-travel map by Arthur's wagon. It goes one way only, to places you have visited.
Start part II the moment part I ends. If the in-game day passes (perhaps only 4 hours), John steals the wagon himself and part II is gone.
Letting time pass after part I locks Pouring Forth Oil II (optional; not an honor mission).
You can meet Mayor Timmins only three times (twice at the Welcome Center, then on the main street by the general store, at least two days apart). Loot the Letter to Mayor Timmins from Belinda (optional) before the third ends; knocking him out costs honor.
Leaving the cellar of Lucky's Cabin locks the two American Dreams letters (optional). Take them before anything else.
Starting it moves the gang to Clemens Point. Finish first: the requests of Sean (Kentucky Bourbon), Mary-Beth (fountain pen), Jack (Penny Dreadful and the thimble), Javier (Oleander Sage), Abigail ($5) and Pearson (a rabbit carcass; it may last until Chapter 4); Jack's Drawing, the Scout Jacket, Dutch's Speech Notes, the Wedding Certificate, the Bride Photograph and Watson's Scrapbook Page (all optional); the Horseshoe Overlook companion activity; Money Lending and Other Sins I & II and III; We Loved Once and True I & II and III; Good, Honest, Snake Oil (other lists keep it open until Chapter 5 or 6; take the early deadline).
The Course of True Love I–III, Money Lending and Other Sins IV, and the Clemens Point camp requests and companion activity end when "Blood Feuds, Ancient and Modern" starts. The warning sits just before that mission, in the next section.
Nigel can be met only six times in the whole game. Loot the Letter to Nigel from Tom (optional) at one of them, before the last is used up; knocking him out costs honor.
Pick up Midnight's Pistol from Billy Midnight's body before you leave the train. It can't be collected later.
If no coach guard in An American Pastoral Scene gave you the Liberty Hat (optional), this is the last chance: after the second wave, check the hogtied man by the cabin before you go in for the reward, and reload the checkpoint if he has no hat.
Take the Lion's Paw from the lion before you leave the barn. The strand can't be replayed, so the paw never comes back.
Before the mission ends, take the Mine Share from Trelawny's caravan and the Rare Rolling Block Rifle from the barn sniper. A replay restores the rifle's Compendium entry but not the rifle.
It runs straight into The Battle of Shady Belle, and the gang leaves Clemens Point for good. Finish first: The Course of True Love I, II and III; Money Lending and Other Sins IV; the Clemens Point companion activity; the item requests from Tilly (a necklace), Hosea (two American Ginseng), Kieran (two Burdock Root), Sadie (the harmonica), Molly (the pocket mirror) and Pearson (the naval compass; it may instead last into Chapter 4); and the Son's Drawing from the Rhodes gunsmith (optional; one list says it stays). Two pickups inside the manor come next and are lost when the mission ends.
The manor's rooms can't be searched again afterwards. Before the mission ends, take the Gold Shield and the Letter to Angelo Bronte from the first room on the left (both optional; the two items above).
Chapter 4 is the last camp chapter. The tithing box, camp item requests and companion activities, this chapter's honor missions (Help a Brother Out, Brothers and Sisters, Fatherhood and Other Dreams, Money Lending V) and, at the strictest reading, The Mercies of Knowledge all end when "Banking, The Old American Art" starts. The full warning sits before that mission, two sections on.
South-east: Victoria Street Station (post office, train tickets, stagecoach) and, nearby, the Horner general store. South: the Eckhart stable and the port along the Lannahechee, where the Grand Korrigan riverboat docks. Centre: Harris Square, with the town hall, De Coursey's tailor and the stop where the red and blue tram lines meet. East: the market by the railway (the pawnbroker fence and the trapper) and the Kuo Chao gunsmith. North: the Bastille Saloon (room, bath, poker) and the barber; Doyle's Tavern sits in the north-east. South-west: the police station, where bounty posters hang. The cathedral, the tallest building, stands on Courtenay Street by the Chinese quarter.
Pick up the Ornate Dagger (optional) the moment the vampire dies; it can't be collected later. Don't go to the meeting while Wanted: he won't show, and the encounter may lock for good.
At the end of the mission Susan leaves Anthony Foreman's fate to you. Let him live: killing him removes his optional bounty poster, which the guide picks up much later in the Saint Denis sweep.
Three optional pickups exist only during "The Gilded Cage": the Theatre Ticket (the smoking guests), Algernon's Business Card (the choking guest) and the Letter to Bronte from the Mayor (the desk by the ledger drawer). Take them before the mission ends.
Try to save the Wittemore suit (optional) as an outfit before "A Fine Night of Debauchery" ends; no shop sells it. Whether saving works without a glitch is uncertain.
Loot the Electric Chair Blueprint (optional) from Professor Bell's body before you leave the gallows; it is found nowhere else.
Before you ride away from Brandywine Drop, take the revolver from Calloway's body. It locks: Calloway's Revolver (optional).
The Inventor's Note and the Inventor's Plan (both optional) are in the Doverhill lab only during part III. Take both before the visit ends.
Before you carry Bronte out, take the List of Accounts and the Telegram to Police Chief Lambert from the desk in his office (both optional). The mission ends the chance for good.
The biggest lockout in the guide. The bank job ends the camp chapters, and with them the tithing box, item requests, camp upgrades and companion activities. Tick all of these first. Camp requests: Bill (Hair Pomade); Susan (two seasoning herbs); Charles (moonshine, then Oleander Sage); Dutch (the pipe from Vetter's Echo) and his Vaquero Rider Spurs (optional); Lenny (a pocket watch); Hosea ("The Case of the Shrew in the Fog" from Hagen Orchards). Trophies: Give to the Poor ($250 of your own in the box, all told); Errand Boy (five requests delivered); Friends With Benefits (the Shady Belle companion activity above, after one at each earlier camp). Honor missions (Lending a Hand needs every one): Help a Brother Out; Brothers and Sisters, One and All; Fatherhood and Other Dreams; Money Lending and Other Sins V, with the Letter to Nate from Momma (optional). Other: every part of The Mercies of Knowledge; the Property Deed from the Central Union Railroad Camp and Catherine's Brooch from the burnt-out Braithwaite Manor (both optional).
Seven species live only here: three macaws, the Red-footed Booby and three boas. Zoologist and Skin Deep don't need them, but they have compendium entries and the island can't be revisited. Take them now, before either mission: from La Capilla go to the waterfall for the macaws, follow the river for the booby, then go downhill to the snake spot and cycle it (the boas also need tracking). Arthur has no journal here, so they get entries but no sketches. The Cuban Land Crab and Green Iguana also live on Guarma; the guide lists both later at Flat Iron Lake, but they count if you take them here.
Guarma free roam runs from the end of Welcome to the New World until you finish the second of "A Kind and Benevolent Despot" and "Savagery Unleashed" (either order; here that is Savagery Unleashed). From then on Hell Hath No Fury and Paradise Mercifully Departed follow with no free roam, and the boat home closes the island for good. Finish first (all optional): the Scarlet, Blue-and-yellow and Great Green Macaws, the Red-footed Booby, the Red, Rainbow and Sunglow Boas, and the Sun Hat.
It is the last mission of Chapter 5: the gang moves to Beaver Hollow and Chapter 6 begins. Items said to last "until Chapter 6" count as lost from its start. Finish first (all optional): the Zoological Compendium and Rambles Through Woods and Plains, the two books in Arthur's tent (Chapter 2); the Bucket Hat from an Appleseed Timber worker at Monto's Rest, north-east of Strawberry; and the Letter from St. Luke's Academy, on a mauled worker at the same timber camp once wolves attack it (gone sooner if the camp has finished its last stage).
Every honor change in this chapter counts half again as much, and this guide's ending needs Arthur's honor at the top: Do Not Seek Absolution also won't start below level 4 of 8. The guide checks the bar at Extreme Personality (after Money Lending VI & VII) and again before Our Best Selves. Fast travel from the camp map costs nothing this chapter.
Take the Liability Agreement (and the $50) from the table before you go.
At Riggs Station, accept Penelope's Bracelet; refuse it and it is gone.
The Owl Feather Trinket comes only if you said yes to Charles in A Rage Unleashed and take the relics without killing anyone.
Starting it ends Of Men and Angels (Sister Calderón leaves for Mexico). Captain Monroe leaves for good at the end of this mission, so finish Archeology for Beginners and Honor, Amongst Thieves (he offers it only during Archeology) first; both are Lending a Hand honor missions. Swanson and Trelawny leave camp after it.
Loot a soldier inside Fort Wallace for the Letter to Martin from Father before the escape.
Loot the last O'Driscoll for the Letter to Tom from Colm before the mission ends.
At the strictest reading, starting it closes Money Lending and Other Sins VI & VII (and with it Lending a Hand). The route did it long ago; if you skipped it, do it now.
After the last mission of Chapter 6, play passes to John. Arthur's weapons, items and clothes carry over; his cash, the horses he owns and a few one-off valuables (Jimmy Brooks's pen among them) do not. Keep treasure maps and other valuables unsold for John rather than spending them as Arthur, and leave the Ancient Viking Comb in the Old Tomb for him.
Starting it runs straight into the last mission of Chapter 6 with no free roam between, and nothing below can be done after. Honor missions (Lending a Hand): The Course of True Love IV and V; Do Not Seek Absolution I and II; Archeology for Beginners; Mrs. Sadie Adler, Widow; and the Lending a Hand trophy itself (Honor, Amongst Thieves closed earlier). Strangers: Arcadia for Amateurs III (herd the horses); Fundraiser, the $20 donation in Saint Denis (optional); The Widow of Willard's Rest I to III and the Letter from Charlotte (optional). Horses and hats (optional): the Mahogany Bay Tennessee Walker and the Raven Black Shire; the Classic Raccoon Mountain Hat from Jon in Valentine, the Newsboy Cap from Cornwall's men and the Military Mountie Hat from the army. Documents and places (optional): the Chelonian Handbill from Anders Helgerson; the Wild Man's Journal; the Letter from Ms. Hobbs (mail hunting requests 1 to 4, then collect it at any post office); Braithwaites' Secret by Braithwaite Manor. Honor: the bar should be full (Extreme Personality) for the ending this guide takes; top it up first if it isn't.
With low honor, helping John ends with Micah shooting Arthur. Going back for the money leads to a knife fight with Micah: with high honor Arthur slashes Micah's eye and still dies at sunrise; with low honor Micah stabs him to death (another account has Micah shoot him). No trophy or 100% item needs these; replay the mission from the Story menu to see them.
You now play as John Marston, eight years on. Arthur's weapons, satchel items and clothes reach you at the end of Motherhood (until then you can't change clothes or buy guns); his cash, the horses he owned and a few one-off valuables are gone. The whole map is open, including New Austin and the Great Plains around Blackwater. These two Epilogue sections do the story and what it can lock; collectibles, animals and the rest of the map wait for the region sweeps after the credits.
Knock off and pick up the Worn Flat Cap before the mission ends.
Save John's Gambler's Hat before you wear any other hat. Motherhood ends with a change of outfit, so do it now.
Take the Giant Boar Tusk from the body before you ride off.
Starting the story's last mission ends Charles's eagle feather request; hand it in first. Nothing else in this guide closes here.
From here the guide rides one loop out of Beecher's Hope, one region per section: Great Plains and Tall Trees, New Austin, Big Valley, Grizzlies West, Grizzlies East, Cumberland Forest and Valentine, the Heartlands, Roanoke Ridge (two parts), Bluewater Marsh, Bayou Nwa, Saint Denis, Scarlett Meadows (two parts), then the treasure hunts and a wrap-up. Almost nothing in the sweeps can be lost; the few one-off finds are flagged where you meet them: Zhou Yi's letter on a body in New Austin, the sculptor's note in the Grizzlies East, a letter on a burnt body at the Heartlands oil derrick, the Manito Glade hermit's Rare Shotgun in Roanoke Ridge and the Rare Orchids Order after Algernon's last list. Everything else can wait. For each animal, press Study while it is in your binoculars (no tracking needed), then kill it and skin, pluck or pick it up; Eagle Eye picks out small finds such as bones, crayfish and fish in the water. If a species won't show, sleep or reload a save to re-roll the local wildlife.
Owls and wolf packs come out after dark. Wait at Bear Claw for nightfall: all three horned owls perch on the ruined cabins here, and gray wolves roam the woods around them. In the morning, ride west to Aurora Basin, where sunny weather suits its legendary fish.
From Blackwater, on the shore of Flat Iron Lake, ride to Thieves' Landing on New Austin's eastern edge, where the Lower Montana meets the San Luis by the lake. The New Austin sweep starts there.
The Del Lobo gang holds all four of the state's hideouts: Thieves' Landing, Fort Mercer, Gaptooth Breach and Solomon's Folly. The state's only post office is at Benedict Point, for mailing legendary fish to Gill and paying off a bounty on your head. Stagecoaches run from MacFarlane's Ranch, Armadillo and Tumbleweed, and visited towns join the camp fast-travel map. The three New Austin legendary animals appear once "The Wheel" is done.
Search the body for the Letter to Zhou Yi from Zhou Wei (optional) before you ride on.
Gila monsters come out mostly after dark. Make camp or wait near the outcrop until night, then ride slowly through the Gaptooth Ridge scrub watching the ground.
Lady Slipper orchids grow on the ground across Big Valley and glow in Eagle Eye. Algernon's second list (Saint Denis sweep) wants seven, but until that list is in your hands they stop appearing once you hold six: pick six as you ride this loop. The seventh is one short trip once the list is open.
Ride on south-east of the station towards Lone Mule Stead, the farm near Bard's Crossing from the Chapter 3 parley, and wait for dark there; make camp to pass the time. The quail and orioles above are around the farm too.
The Grizzlies West rise just north of Hanging Dog Ranch: the next section starts here. Gray wolves were taken at the Bear Claw night stop; if you still need one, packs roam round this ranch after dark.
Most of this loop is deep snow. Change into a heavy coat and hat before you ride up: in light clothes the cold drains your health core.
Valentine lies just south of this stretch of the river. Ride to its post office in the station at the south-east corner of town, mail the Sockeye to Gill, and come back to the rock wall: the next section starts here.
Dragon's Mouth orchids grow on the ground in the Grizzlies East and glow in Eagle Eye. Algernon's last list (Saint Denis sweep) wants five, but until that list is in your hands they stop appearing once you hold four: pick four on this ride. The fifth is one short trip once the list is open.
Before you climb down, take the Note from the Sculptor from the hanged man's body: shoot the rope, then loot him straight away.
Timber wolves come out at night in the south of Cumberland Forest. Make camp in these woods and wait for dark before you ride on toward Valentine.
Before you ride on, take the Letter from Cornwall Kerosene & Tar from Mr. Varley's burnt body.
Before you ride off, pick up the hermit's Rare Shotgun from the ground: once you leave it, it's gone. Hogtying him is enough; he doesn't need to die. Make this one of your first visits: he may leave for good after a third meeting.
Bring a Special Lake Lure and a Special River Lure (the Lagras bait shop) for the two legendary fish, and small game arrows for the birds at Fort Brennand. Butcher Creek and Van Horn both answer any crime with gunfire.
Sparrow's Egg orchids grow on the ground between Roanoke Valley and Elysian Pool, the stretch this leg starts on, and glow in Eagle Eye. Algernon's last list (Saint Denis sweep) wants ten, but until that list is in your hands they stop appearing once you hold nine: pick nine here. The tenth is one short trip once the list is open.
Moccasin orchids grow on the ground around Butcher Creek, next on this ride. Algernon's second list wants ten, but until that list is in your hands they stop appearing once you hold nine: pick nine round the village. The tenth is one short trip once the list is open.
Algernon's lists in Saint Denis want 20 heron plumes and 30 spoonbill plumes, and plumes can be stocked in any number before a list asks: skin every heron and spoonbill you drop in this marsh and the next, best around noon. Cigar orchids grow on trees here too; his third list wants seven, but until it is given they stop appearing once you hold six, so pick six.
Ride on south into the city. Mail the Legendary Bullhead Catfish to Gill from the post office at the station in the south-east, and sell the Oryx pelt to the trapper at the market. Then head back north out of the city for Canebreak Manor.
Make camp near the Trapper's Cabin and ride the marsh after dark. Night Folk roam the bayou at night, so stay alert. The next stretch starts at Lagras; if it is still dark when you reach Macomb's End beyond it, take its bats then.
Alligators lie along the banks all over this loop, from Lagras to Crawdad Willies. Most stay still until you get close, but one grab can kill you: look along the shore before you wade or swim, and drop one with a rifle shot to the head.
Plumes and gator eggs stock in any number, so take them all as you go: herons and spoonbills along the water around noon (his lists want 20 and 30), egrets at Crawdad Willies (5 of each), and gator eggs from the nests by adult gators here and round Shady Belle (25). His first list is already open, so pick all 15 Lady of the Night orchids in the west. Every other orchid stops appearing one short of its list's count until that list is given, so pick: Rat Tail 9 round Lagras and Lakay, Spider 4 by Bayall Edge, Queen's 4 in the swamp between Lagras and Lakay, Acuna's Star 2 and Cigar 6 in the north-east of the bayou, Ghost 4 round Shady Belle, Clamshell 4 on the river banks west of Saint Denis. Orchids glow in Eagle Eye.
From Macomb's End to Caliga Hall you ride through western Bayou Nwa, north of the Kamassa, where Lady of the Night orchids grow on the trees (also on Caliga Hall's northern banks). Algernon's open first list wants 15: pick until you have them, and the first order is a plain hand-in.
Algernon gives one list per visit to his greenhouse, and the next only when the last is handed in; the open list is in your satchel (Documents, Exotic Collector's List). If you followed the sweeps' pick-ahead tips, you already hold every plume and egg and all but the last orchid of each kind: those stop growing one short until their list is given, so lists 2, 4 and 5 each need a short trip (by train from Victoria Street Station) before the hand-in. Orchids glow in Eagle Eye.
Between Algernon's final visit and a post office, don't quit or load a save: once the game has saved (autosaves count), a reload makes the Rare Orchids Order (optional) disappear. From the station, the next section heads south-west to the rail bridge and on toward Shady Belle.
Silver foxes come out after dark. Make camp near Mattock Pond and wait for night, then ride the country north of Rhodes.
That was the last region. The treasure hunts follow as their own pass, since their maps cross the whole map in a fixed order, and then the wrap-up gathers what needs several towns at once: strand finales, the hunting lists, table games and the last challenges.
Each map points to the next stash, so a chain can't be taken out of order; this pass threads the chains into one ride from Rhodes to Mount Shann, with a train or stagecoach where a chain jumps across the map. The Jack Hall Gang chain (Chapter 2) already gave Explorer 2 to 4 and the one finished chain 100% needs. The six Poisonous Trail and High Stakes finds below cover Explorer 5 to 10; an optional Landmarks map counts as a find too, so a rank may pop before its item. Gold bars fetch $500 each at a fence: Rhodes, Emerald Ranch, Saint Denis and Van Horn have one, West Elizabeth and New Austin none.
Keep the last bars (six from Mount Shann, one from Coot's Chapel) for the next fence you pass: none trades in West Elizabeth or New Austin. The wrap-up starts close by, at the Strawberry post office and then Francis Sinclair's cabin north-west of Strawberry.
These tasks need several towns or the whole map, so ride the stagecoaches and trains between stops. The Bandit ranks come late on purpose: every one of them costs honor. The gold bars from the last treasure hunts can't be sold in West Elizabeth or New Austin, which have no fence: the first fence on this route is the pawnbroker in Saint Denis.
From the Mount Shann sundial, ride down to Strawberry Depot and collect the letters waiting for you: Francis Sinclair's and Jeremy Gill's invitations, and Deborah MacGuiness's if it has come. If you still have bone or carving locations to mail, mail them now, then sleep a day or two before you collect that invitation.
After the finale's scene, take the Old Brass Compass (optional) from the cabin table before you leave: the door may be locked afterwards.
Gambler 7 is open now: beat the five finger fillet player behind the brick building south of the saloon. Then take Ms. Hobbs's fifth hunting list from the poster at the post office on the pier; the hunt comes later in this section.
Rank 10 asks for one broken wild horse of each of nine breeds, and only breaks made from now on count. This section passes them all: Hungarian Halfbred and Kentucky Saddler around and south-west of Blackwater (now); Appaloosa south of Wapiti near Donner Falls, and Mustang and Tennessee Walker in the Heartlands (after Gambler 7); American Standardbred and Morgan on the Little Creek River; American Paint south of Tumbleweed and Nokota south of Armadillo, the last two.
Before leaving Valentine, ride up into the Grizzlies East for the Appaloosa south of Wapiti, near Donner Falls, and break a Mustang and a Tennessee Walker in the Heartlands on the way back.
If Uncle's home-remedy request is still open, bring the milkweed, Kentucky bourbon, peppermint, hair pomade and a whole skunk (plentiful in Black Bone Forest) while you are at Beecher's Hope.
From Mount Shann, ride to the Little Creek River in the north of West Elizabeth and break an American Standardbred and a Morgan.
Make a manual save before you start Gill's outing: as it ends, his hat can land in the San Luis River out of reach. If it does, reload and play it again; if not, pick up the Fisherman's Hat (Jeremy Gill's hat) (optional) before you ride off.
| Mission | Chapter | Why it is hard |
|---|---|---|
| Archeology for Beginners | 6 | Taking the relics unseen inside 1:30; a soldier outside may spot you even in stealth. |
| The Course of True Love II | 3 | Reaching Penelope unspotted inside 3:00, harder with the replay loadout. |
| Horsemen, Apocalypses | 4 | Sidearms only, 70% accuracy, 15 headshots and no health items in one run. |
| Just a Social Call | 6 | Reaching the horses inside 2:45 at the end, hard without knowing the way. |
| The Joys of Civilization | 4 | Catching the urchin before the market without stamina upgrades. |
| A Fork in the Road; Visiting Hours; Motherhood | 5; 6; Epilogue | Tight timers players report (3:05, 9:00, 1:30). |
Open Progress > Total Completion and find the unticked row. The usual causes: Health, Stamina or Dead Eye stuck at level 8 because the reinforced sets were never bought; a robbery done inside a mission, or an ordinary coach or till, which don't count (a tip-off coach and a shop with a hidden side business do); one grave site that holds two of the nine graves; Ms. Hobbs's last list, which only appears after the story; the two New Austin gang hideouts; and Herbalist 9's New Austin herbs.
Online trophies don't touch your story save, and nothing here is missable: Online is still running and none of the 17 is known to be out of reach. The Platinum needs every one. Tips date from Online's launch, so prices and menus may differ now.
| Trophy | Grade | Section |
|---|---|---|
| Back in the Mud | Bronze | 1. Chapter 1: Colter |
| Just a Scratch | Bronze | 1. Chapter 1: Colter |
| To Greener Pastures | Bronze | 3. Chapter 2: Emerald Ranch, Strawberry and the move south |
| Settling Feuds | Bronze | 5. Chapter 3: Valentine, Big Valley and the Braithwaite feud |
| Washed Ashore | Bronze | 8. Chapter 4: Lagras and the bank |
| No Traitors | Bronze | 10. Chapter 5: Back to the mainland and Lakay |
| Third Time Lucky | Bronze | 11. Chapter 6: Beaver Hollow |
| Redemption | Silver | 11. Chapter 6: Beaver Hollow |
| Cowboy Builder | Bronze | 13. Epilogue Part 2: Beecher's Hope |
| Endless Summer | Gold | 13. Epilogue Part 2: Beecher's Hope |
| Lending a Hand | Silver | 11. Chapter 6: Beaver Hollow |
| Best in the West | Gold | 29. Post-game wrap-up |
| Gold Rush | Silver | 29. Post-game wrap-up |
| Friends With Benefits | Bronze | 8. Chapter 4: Lagras and the bank |
| Hobby Horse | Bronze | 4. Chapter 3: Clemens Point, Rhodes and the Grays |
| Breaking and Entering | Bronze | 4. Chapter 3: Clemens Point, Rhodes and the Grays |
| Artificial Intelligence | Bronze | 7. Chapter 4: The Gilded Cage, the Heartlands and Roanoke Ridge |
| Take From the Rich | Bronze | 4. Chapter 3: Clemens Point, Rhodes and the Grays |
| Give to the Poor | Bronze | 2. Chapter 2: Horseshoe Overlook and Valentine |
| Pony Up | Bronze | 13. Epilogue Part 2: Beecher's Hope |
| Extreme Personality | Bronze | 11. Chapter 6: Beaver Hollow |
| Western Stranger | Bronze | 7. Chapter 4: The Gilded Cage, the Heartlands and Roanoke Ridge |
| Bountiful | Bronze | 29. Post-game wrap-up |
| Collector's Item | Silver | 25. Sweep: Saint Denis |
| Paying Respects | Bronze | 27. Sweep: Scarlett Meadows: Southfield Flats, Flat Iron Lake, Dewberry Creek and Pleasance |
| Errand Boy | Bronze | 3. Chapter 2: Emerald Ranch, Strawberry and the move south |
| It's Art | Bronze | 29. Post-game wrap-up |
| Self Sufficient | Bronze | 7. Chapter 4: The Gilded Cage, the Heartlands and Roanoke Ridge |
| Skin Deep | Bronze | 27. Sweep: Scarlett Meadows: Southfield Flats, Flat Iron Lake, Dewberry Creek and Pleasance |
| Zoologist | Bronze | 27. Sweep: Scarlett Meadows: Southfield Flats, Flat Iron Lake, Dewberry Creek and Pleasance |
| It was THIS Big! | Bronze | 11. Chapter 6: Beaver Hollow |
| Locked and Loaded | Bronze | 2. Chapter 2: Horseshoe Overlook and Valentine |
| Grin and Bear it | Bronze | 16. Sweep: Big Valley |
| Trusty Steed | Bronze | 3. Chapter 2: Emerald Ranch, Strawberry and the move south |
| Breakout | Bronze | 30. Appendix: Red Dead Online |
| Series Major | Bronze | 30. Appendix: Red Dead Online |
| Gun For Hire | Bronze | 30. Appendix: Red Dead Online |
| Eventful | Bronze | 30. Appendix: Red Dead Online |
| Buckle Up | Bronze | 30. Appendix: Red Dead Online |
| The Real Deal | Bronze | 30. Appendix: Red Dead Online |
| Horses for Courses | Bronze | 30. Appendix: Red Dead Online |
| Getting Started | Bronze | 30. Appendix: Red Dead Online |
| Notorious | Gold | 30. Appendix: Red Dead Online |
| All's Fair | Bronze | 30. Appendix: Red Dead Online |
| Home Comforts | Bronze | 30. Appendix: Red Dead Online |
| Non-Regulation | Bronze | 30. Appendix: Red Dead Online |
| Posse Up | Bronze | 30. Appendix: Red Dead Online |
| Master Craftsman | Bronze | 30. Appendix: Red Dead Online |
| Butchered | Bronze | 30. Appendix: Red Dead Online |
| Picked to Perfection | Bronze | 30. Appendix: Red Dead Online |
| Strength in Numbers | Bronze | 30. Appendix: Red Dead Online |
| Legend of the West | Platinum | 30. Appendix: Red Dead Online |
Strength in Numbers (a posse of two or more), All's Fair (a rival posse to stop), Series Major (a lobby of players) and The Real Deal (matches of four or more). Eventful hangs on events that start when the game decides. A friend makes all of them quicker.